Critical Update on the Proposed 40% GST for Indian Horse Racing

 (Article has been proofed for Syntax errors and Grammatical mistakes by AI)

The GST Council is scheduled to meet between the 3rd and 4th of September to finalize new tax slabs, which are expected to be rolled out from September 22nd.

A matter of grave concern for the Indian horse racing industry is the proposal to place betting and gambling in a 28% "sin tax" slab with an additional 12% Compensation Cess, resulting in a total effective GST of 40%. Crucially, this tax is proposed to be levied on the full value of the bet (the pool size) rather than on the Gross Gaming Revenue (GGR) or the club's commission.

The Imminent Threat:

If the GST Council adamantly implements this 40% tax on the actual bet value, it will render the entire business model of Indian horse racing financially unviable. Such a high tax burden on the total pool would drastically reduce prize money, discourage ownership, and ultimately lead to the collapse of the industry. In simple terms, Indian racing is as good as dead under this structure.

The Viable Solution:

The only saving grace is to convince the government to apply the GST solely on the club's commission (the platform fee), a model already successfully implemented for financial services like stock market trades. In the stock market, GST is charged only on the broker's fee, not on the entire transaction value. Applying this same principle to horse racing would ensure the industry's sustainability while ensuring the government collects legitimate revenue.

Call to Action:

It is imperative that the Turf Authority of India (TAI) acts immediately. The TAI must submit a comprehensive and compelling representation to the GST Council and the Ministry of Finance. This representation should clearly outline:

• The catastrophic economic impact of a 40% tax on the pool value.
• The successful precedent of taxing only the commission/fee in analogous sectors like stock broking.
• The positive economic contributions of the racing industry (employment, tourism, agricultural support for breeding) that are at risk.

The need of the hour is swift and decisive action from the TAI to secure a fair and rational tax framework before the critical GST Council meeting.

Read more...

From 28% to 40%: A Death Sentence for Horse Racing?

 (The message has been proof checked for Syntax errors and grammatical mistakes by AI)

The recent announcement rationalizing GST into two primary slabs of 5% and 18% offered a glimmer of hope for India's beleaguered horse racing industry, which has been strangled by a punitive 28% GST since 2017. However, this hope is now clouded with alarming uncertainty. Disturbingly, there are indications that the government may adamantly enforce a devastating "sin tax" of 40% on the sport.

Such a move would be nothing short of a death sentence. The previous 28% rate was draconian enough, crippling the legal totalizator and pushing the industry toward collapse while fueling a massive illegal betting ecosystem. A 40% tax is unconscionable and would irrevocably destroy this 150-year-old sport. It would erase the livelihoods of over 1.5 lakh people employed directly and indirectly, many in the agrarian supply chain, while maintaining a glaring double standard. This moral stand against a regulated sport remains absent for other forms of speculation, like the stock markets, which are astronomically larger in volume. The choice is clear: a rational tax rate that allows a legacy industry to survive and contribute, or a prohibitive levy that will kill it outright.

Read more...

PM Announces GST Rate Rationalization: Relief for Horse Racing Industry?

 In a welcome move, the Prime Minister has announced the simplification of GST slabs, reducing them to just two rates of 5% and 18%. This could finally bring much-needed relief to the horse racing industry, which has been burdened by a draconian 28% GST since May 2017. The exorbitant tax rate crippled the legal totalizator system, driving punters towards illegal betting channels. Despite being a regulated sport that employs around 1.5 lakh people directly and indirectly—many in the agrarian sector—the government's harsh GST and TDS policies have severely throttled the industry. Ironically, while moral objections are raised against horse racing, the same scrutiny is absent in far larger speculative markets like stock trading, which operates at volumes thousands of times higher. The revision in GST rates could be a crucial step towards reviving this struggling yet economically significant sector.

Read more...